Credit: Image by ErikaWittliebSource

Luxury Homes for Sale in Settlers Mill, Williamsburg, VA

Settlers Mill is a lovely cul de sac neighborhood found in the southwestern portion of Williamsburg, Virginia.

The neighborhood offers an intimate living environment that’s a perfect option for buyers looking for a move-in-ready home for their families. Settlers Mill was developed to provide a classic suburban living environment with lovely single-family homes, tree-lined streets, kid-friendly outdoor spaces, meticulously landscaped yards, and green spaces. If you’re in the market for your dream home in Williamsburg, you’ll surely want to take a look at the Settlers Mill subdivision. If you have additional questions regarding particular listings in the area or would like help from a local realtor buying properties here, please feel free to reach out to our team today.

BEAUTIFUL SURROUNDINGS: Taking a drive through the subdivision, you’ll surely love the tremendous curb appeal that Settlers Mill provides. Homes are beautifully built, and front yards are well kept to help maintain the neighborhood’s aesthetics. Mature trees line the paved streets in the suburb, and the back of most homes are also filled with tree lines that provide ample shade during the summer months.

WELL-PRICED HOMES: Real Estate in Settlers Mill is priced slightly above the median price point of Williamsburg, Virginia. Buyers interested in the area can get relatively good deals on spacious single-family homes that provide comfortable living arrangements for large families looking to move into the city.

QUIET LOCATION: Settlers Mill is ideally located a reasonable distance from Williamsburg’s busier tourist destinations and business districts. Residents can avoid high-traffic areas, which will surely be attractive for those looking to buy a home they plan to move into with their children.

Market Overview

Williamsburg, VA Real Estate Information

Median Listing Price


Median Price Per Sq Ft


Average Days on Market


Median Price of Sold Homes


Home Ownership Percentage


Median Rent


Homes in Settlers Mill, Williamsburg, VA

5 Real Estate Facts About Settlers Mill, Williamsburg, VA

  • Homes for sale in Settlers Mill are comprised of single-family homes priced between the high $400,000s to mid $600,000s.
  • Homes here feature iconic Colonial architecture with exquisite red brick masonry with large white framed windows.
  • You’ll also find houses with beautiful wood exteriors and classic front porches featuring large white pillars.
  • Overall the neighborhood retains the historic feel that’s a common theme in Williamsburg, Virginia.
  • Households in the area are pretty spacious, with most homes having two-floor designs with large interiors with three to five bedrooms and baths.
Find Your Home

Latest Homes for Sale in Settlers Mill, Williamsburg, VA

On the map

Settlers Mill Map

Settlers Mill is a lovely cul de sac suburb that you can find in the southwestern portion of Williamsburg, Virginia. The two main entryways of the neighborhood connect Ironbound Road to the west and Jamestown Road to the south. These highways make up the borders of the subdivision, with Mill Creek serving as its eastern border and Hickory Singpost Road linking it to the north.

Untitled design (28)
Take the next step

Ready to take the next step?

I pride myself on knowing the neighborhood. I live here, I work here, I volunteer here, and I raise my family here. Buying a home is much more involved than selecting a house…it’s choosing a community to put down roots. It’s about discovering a lifestyle that fits. We love to share our deep knowledge of the area with our clients and help them find the perfect community to call home.

Meet the locals

Who Lives in Williamsburg, VA



Median Age


Median Household Income




Household size


Cost of living



Things to do in Settlers Mill

Settlers Mill Amenities

Residents in Settlers Mill can use a variety of amenities, including picnic areas, a clubhouse, a swimming pool, a playground, tennis and pickleball courts, and more.

Virginia Capital Trail Jamestown Trailhead

Start your bike ride through Historic Jamestown at this trailhead located to the southwest of the neighborhood.

Powhatan Creek Park and Blueway

A nearby public space that offers a boat ramp that launches into Powhatan Creek, fishing spots, picnic areas, and scenic trails.

Jamestown Pie Company

A family-owned bakeshop serving freshly baked pies and gourmet pizzas.


Schools in Settlers Mill

School NameGradesAdmission
Greenwood Christian AcademyPK - 5Private
Clara Byrd Baker ElementaryPK - 5Public
Berkeley Middle School6 - 8Public
Jamestown High School9 - 12Public